I enjoy listening to Chuck Klosterman when he is a guest on Bill Simmon’s podcast. We are similar in that we were both raised in small towns in the upper midwest, Klosterman in North Dakota and me in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan. I am four years older than him, but we had a similar childhood and adolescence. We also both love college football. Klosterman, in this book, writes essays about the place American football has in our culture and a lot of different angles about the sport, ranging from the differences between Canadian and American football, football as the perfect television product, the outsized role it plays in defining or reflecting American values. American football is a complicated game with 22 different positions (not including special teams) each position player needing a different set of skills. It makes it hard to follow for people who have not played or were brought up around the game.
I thought his most provocative idea was the future demise of football in our culture. He compares it to horse racing in the 20th century. Horse racing, along with boxing and baseball used to be the major sports followed in our culture. Today, it is American football, basketball, and baseball. His theory, which I’ve heard before, is horse racing fell in popularity because society lost their connection to horses. Before the automobile became popular, most people rode horses or were around horses on a farm. They had a connection to horses that naturally led to them to follow races closely. As horses faded in importance and less and less people had every day contact with the horse, the popularity of big (Kentucky Derby, Preakness, and Belmont) and small races faded as well. Today, it is a niche pastime, with the highlights of the Kentucky Derby being shown online as the only time it reaches a national audience. As I write this, I recall the Melbourne Cup, the Australian equivalent to the Kentucky Derby. When I lived in Perth, Western Australia, from 2000 to 2002, it was a big event at our school. I also went to “the trots”, harness racing, as well and betting on the horses was more popular there than in the USA. I always felt Australia was 20 years behind the USA, and that fits with that view.
Klosterman sees a connection to American football, also starting. Fewer and fewer people are playing youth and high school football. I see that at my high school (West Iron County High School), it is difficult to get enough students to go out to form a full squad. The research is showing that concussions may cause brain damage, and families with teenagers of average athletic ability are deciding it is not worth it. Like horse racing in the 20th century, Klosterman predicts football will decline in the middle of the 21st century.
I was particularly interested in his view that the second most popular sport, NCAA university football, will also decline because it is getting to be too much like the NFL. I, like many others, loved the regionalism of college football. The Big Ten Conference represented the northern Great Lakes and midwest and they played a conservative, run-oriented style of football. The SEC (South Eastern Conference) represented a football is the most important thing in our lives, and the teams of from the deep south played a more open version of the game. The West Coast passing game (Pacific 10 Conference) was again another style. When these teams met in bowl games, it was fascinating to watch the cultures and styles clash. The regionalism of college football is being lost with the influx of money. Michigan, Ohio State, Georgia, Alabama, USC are spending for the same players. Klosterman thinks it will become a lesser version or minor league of the NFL and lose popularity because of it. With players getting paid and having the right to transfer schools annually, their ties as “students” are becoming tenuous. Why should I cheer for the Michigan State Spartans, the traditional agricultural and teachers college representing the rural parts of Michigan, when the players are only their to be football players without studying and learning with actual students.
I recommend this book to both football fans and people who don’t like sports. Klosterman is always provocative and interesting for non-sports readers.















































