Latest Reading: “A Guardian and a Thief” by Megha Majumdar

Majumdar’s novel takes place over seven days in Kolkata (formerly known as Calcutta), India. It is in the future, and climate-induced floods and droughts have created famine in the country. The story follows two desperately poor and starving families, both trying to escape their situations. Majumdar’s writing helped me understand the plight of the poor and the lengths people will go to survive and take care of loved ones. We will eventually see the impact of climate change on our food supply in some parts of the world, maybe in my lifetime, but certainly in the lifetimes of my children and grandchildren.

In the first family (the guardian), the main character “Ma” is the mother of a two-year old toddler, and also lives with her elderly father. Her husband found a job at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor and secured paperwork for them to join him in Michigan in the “climate visa” program. In the week leading up to their departure, their passports with the precious visas inside are stolen by “Boomba”, who we learn recently arrived in the city from the countryside. Ma runs a shelter and food pantry in the city where Boomba sometimes stayed. The story kept me turning pages to find out if they could retrieve the passports and leave for a better life in my home state of Michigan.

I liked how Majumdar described how Boomba became a thief. His family (parents and younger brother) is living in a makeshift shelter on the verge of starvation in a village several hours outside of Kolkata. He is a self-starter and comes to the city to find them a proper home and enough food to live a decent life.

The novel, in a sense, is a post-apocalyptic story of humanity competing for scarcer and scarcer resources. It is subtle, though, and shows in real time the breakdown of the institutions that protect the dignity of our lives. For example, the police don’t care to investigate the break-in of Ma’s home because they are dealing with outbreaks of violence throughout the city. The regular sources of food procurement, street markets, super markets, etc. are slowly turning into black markets, and people are forced to protect their dwindling food supplies. This could eventually lead to a Mad Max-type world with warlords and violence being a part of everyday life.

It also made me think about the responsibility of richer countries like the USA. Our extravagant lifestyles, powered by fossil fuels, are the cause of the famine. What responsibility do we have to take care of the climate refugees?

Showing my age, I could relate to Ma’s father, “Dadu”. He didn’t want to leave for Michigan in part because, “There would be nobody in that place acquainted with his boyhood self.” He knew he would be a “diminished version of himself – uncertain of social mores, unaccostomed to the accents, wary of car culture.” I see where the call to home comes from as one ages. The other vignette from Dadu that resonated with me is when he buys his granddaughter a painting of a rhino, instead of using all of his funds on food supplies. “That would be his mode of immortality,” that the daughter would have the painting, long after he is dead. He imagines her saying, “My dadu got it for me. I had a Dadu once, whom you never met.”

I learned about Ibn Battuta, a 14th-century Moroccan explorer who is the equivalent to the West’s Marco Polo. I had seen the name but didn’t know much about this life.

I won’t spoil the ending of the novel in this blog post. It is a tragic story for all involved, including the millions of climate refugees who are not featured in the novel.

Latest Reading: Essex Dogs by Dan Jones

The setting of the novel is the Hundred Years War, which was fought between England and France and various allies between 1337 and 1453. I didn’t know much about the war except that Joan of Arc played a role in rallying the French. This novel and inquiries to Chat GPT helped me learn a lot about this conflict. England’s King Edward III started the war by laying claim to the French throne because of his mom’s lineage. 

The Essex Dogs are a military unit of 10 soldiers in Edward’s army. Essex is a region in England where the main character, FitzTalbot Loveday is from. The novel follows them as the English army is invading Normandy in the summer of 1346. It is like a Band of Brothers but set in medieval times, ala Game of Thrones with longbows, knights, sword fighting, cavalry, etc. The English marauded through Norman towns which reflects early English victories in the real 100 Years War. I won’t spoil the ending for you, but by the end of the book, you are hoping the guys can survive the many battles against the French and their German allies. It is not a deep, life-changing novel, but it is entertaining and I like learning history through historical fiction.

What changed for me with this book was using Chat GPT to provide background on the historical figures and events mentioned in the book. In the actual 100 Years War, the French eventually won. The use of the long bow was a game-changer in warfare and the conflicts ushered in the first ideas of nationalism and the nation-state. Joan of Arc was a real person, a French military hero, and a Catholic Saint. There is a mysterious woman character in the book, but the story takes place before she was born. 

The story reminded me that if I had an opportunity to time travel, I would prefer to travel to the future. Life was difficult back then for the vast majority of people. In the novel, the descriptions of the lives of peasants in the fortified towns and villages and the English soldiers on a campaign are miserable. The novel helped me fall back to sleep this week and I enjoyed going into their medieval world. I also would love to visit Normandy someday. It seems like an interesting part of the world with D-Day, the sea, and the countryside.

I always pick up new vocabulary words when I read and below is a list.

  • flitches – slabs of bacon (old English) or a piece of timber
  • chevauchée – Medieval military technique of burning and pillaging enemy territory to reduce productivity (ex. burn fields, kill horses)
  • squire – attendant to a knight before becoming a knight
  • feckless – good for nothing; weak